This
is a memorial for Anna, a sexual assault survivor from Hobart and William Smith
Colleges. No, she has not lost her life, but like many other sexual assault
survivors, she has lost her sense of safety. A few weeks into her first
semester at the school, she attended a fraternity party with some of her
friends. While there, she became very drunk and got separated from her friends.
One of her friends eventually found her bent over a pool table with a senior
football player sexually assaulting her from behind. She was taken back to her
dorm, but later that night was taken to the hospital. A rape exam showed “blunt force
trauma within the last 24 hours indicating ‘intercourse with either multiple
partners, multiple times or that the intercourse was very forceful.’” She
accused three football players of raping her and their semen was found in her
vagina, in her rectum and on her underwear.
While she had the option of turning to the police, she chose to let
the campus administration deal with her case. The school, however, was
unprepared and grossly mismanaged it. At the disciplinary hearing, the
“panelists interrupted her answers, at times misrepresented evidence and asked
about a campus-police report she had not seen. The hearing proceeded before her
rape-kit results were known, and the medical records indicating trauma were not
shown to two of the three panel members.” They interrogated Anna on matters
such as what she had to drink that night, who she kissed and how she was
dancing, while repeatedly interrupting her account of the night. They ignored
evidence showing that the three accused football players had initially lied to
police officers. Mere hours after talking to the last witness, they cleared all
three-football players of all charges. Anna’s troubles, however, did not end
there. Once students found out that she had accused members of the schools’
favorite sports team, she faced much harassment. Physical threats and
obscenities were found on her dormitory door and she was pushed in the dining
hall. Despite this, Anna eventually decided to return to the school saying that
she needed to be there to help other survivors.
While Anna survived her attack, she has lost her sense of
safety. Like many others before her, she did not believe that she could be sexually assaulted. She
recounted that days before her attack, she and her friends were joking about
the rape statistics and how it could possibly affect them. The rape itself took
away her feeling of being safe at her own school, but it is not the only way
Anna was deprived of her feeling of safety. Like some other students at Hobart
and William Smith, Anna chose to press charges against her assailants. She
believed that the administration would remove the students from the campus and
perhaps give her some sense of safety back. Instead they not only cleared the
players of all charges, they even released her name in letters to students. The
school claimed that it was legally obligated to release this information to
students who may be called to testify. This, however, allowed Anna’s name to
get around campus, where people began to harass her. The way the school handled
her case destroyed Anna’s feeling of safety in reporting. It shattered the idea
that the school would provide justice and instead gave her more reason to feel
unsafe. Anna eventually chose to return to Hobart and William Smith Colleges
saying, “Someone needs to help survivors there.” Clearly, she believes that she
and other survivors are not safe in seeking help from the school.
Anna’s case, unfortunately, is not uncommon on campuses across
America. Statistics show that 1 in 20 women will be sexually assaulted during
their years in college. So, while many may believe that it cannot happen to
them, unfortunately, sometimes it does. Her case also highlights the lack of
safety many students feel in reporting. Underreporting sexual assaults has
always been a problem when dealing with the issue because it underrepresents
its seriousness. Even when reporting rates are high, the statistics are often misconstrued
as that college being rape-prone. Many do not realize that low rape reports do
not mean that it is not happening. It merely means that students do not feel
safe reporting. Anna’s case demonstrates many of the reasons why students feel this
way. Campus sexual assault cases are often mishandled, which results in the accused
being cleared and remaining on campus. The survivors, if they choose to remain
on campus, must then face their attacker almost daily. Like Anna, many rape
survivors often face harassment from other students once it gets out that they
accused another student of rape. These students either blame them for what they
see as false accusations or even for the attack itself. Anna had to face both
of these. Students criticized her for accusing the popular football players.
The panelists, when questioning her, seemed to be trying to find something she
did that could justify the rape. All of this contributes to why many do not
feel safe reporting to either the campus or the police. Instead they often feel
that they must hide it.
Even for those who have not experienced sexual assault, knowing Anna’s
story destroys our sense of safety. When people read stories like this, they
are forced to realize just how often rape occurs and how easily it could happen
to them. They are also forced to recognize the consequences of sexual assault,
which continue long after the rape itself ends. The incidents and how they are
handled create a climate of fear, where many do not feel safe. I chose to tell Anna’s
story because it represents a lot of the problems with campus rape. Not just
that rape happens, but how the police, the campus officials, and the other
students handle it. Combined, they all take away from both the survivor and
others’ sense of safety. So, while this is a memorial for Anna and her losses,
it is also a memorial for so many other men and women out there who no longer
feel safe due to campus sexual assault.